Skip to main content

Scalloped Tomatoes or in other words....Tomato Pudding???

It was lunchtime yesterday and I was hungry, only not for the usual sandwich, salad or leftovers.  It was a cold, rainy day and I wanted something warm and cozy.   What came to mind was an old standard from my childhood.  My mother would open up a jar of home-canned tomatoes into a sauce pan, add soda crackers, butter and some cream and heat until bubbly.  It was spooned into some bowls and always hit the spot.  

Today, I did the usual, adding some basil and parmesan cheese (something my mother never would have done) and was curled up on the couch, listening to the rain and feeling all cozy again!

I started to wonder, as I usually do, where did this come from?  My mother’s old standards have a tradition of being German-born, so I went about researching to confirm its origins.  It was more complicated than I thought. 

In 2009, the Chicago Tribune ran an article in it’s A&E section, telling the story of Tomato pudding as an early-American recipe.   Tomato pudding, as defined in this article, was a Thanksgiving side-dish consisting of bread cubes, butter, brown sugar, orange juice and tomato puree, cooked like a pudding or souffl√©-type dish, in the oven.  It was similar, sweeter and lacked chunks of tomato, which for me, defines the dish. 

My search continued, which led me to an article on RootsWeb (of all places) and another recipe for Tomato Pudding.  This recipe is attributed to a southern cook Helen Nielsen Allen from “The Great Tomato Book”.   What we have here is the similar process of toasting bread (Crouton), pouring a tomato mixture (this time, tomato chunks and NOT puree) and baking in an oven until puffy and bubbling.  We have water used as the liquid, instead of cream or half-and-half.  

I honed my search in on Germany, hoping that I could find some confirmation of the dish having sprouted or at least found root in the motherland.  It was on an Amish Food web site that I discovered a similar recipe to my mother’s than the pudding variations I kept coming across. 

Sometimes its just that old “peasant food” that brings us a sense of cozy!


Comfy Cozy Peasant Creamy Scalloped Tomatoes

1 qt Home-canned tomatoes
            No home canned, use 2 large cans of diced tomatoes
½ c cream or half and half
¼ t baking soda
½ c coarse crumbled saltine crackers
1 T sugar
½ t of fresh chopped basil, thyme, and oregano
salt and pepper to taste
1-2 T butter

Heat tomatoes in a heavy bottom sauce pain.  If you have used home canned, break up your tomatoes to desired size.  

Add cream and baking soda.  Mix.  Over medium heat,  simmer about 5 minutes.

Add crackers and continue cooking until the crackers have puffed up and taken on most of the liquid.  

Stir in sugar, salt, pepper and herbs. 

Turn off heat and add butter.   Stir in and serve. 


Popular posts from this blog

Chocolate Chip Reeses or Rollos Brownie thingys?

I have no idea what to call these, but oh my goodness are they easy and good.  This recipe comes to you via Pinterest.  I tried to trace it all the way back to its originator, but failed.  It just kept going.   So, I do not claim these as mine - although I have tweaked them and will try something new this weekend.  
As the picture indicates, these were done with premade cookie dough, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups and box brownie mix.  Thats the "easy" no frill recipe.   Here it is:
Preheat your oven to 350 degrees.  Spray the insides of a square all edges brownie pan with Pam spray.   Scoop out a heaping tablespoon of premade cookie dough and press into the bottom of each square.  Top the cookie dough with a Reeses Peanut Butter Cup placed upside down.  Then fill up the well with your favorite prepared brownie mix up to 3/4 full.   Bake in oven for 15-18 minutes.  Remove and cool slightly.
Here are some tips:  
You can use cupcake/muffin tins (either small or large) in r…

Chess Squares, Nieman Marcus Bars, Paula Deen and Gooey Butter Cake....The real origin

So, I saw this recipe on Pinterest a few weeks ago and thought, hmmm.  I need to try this! With my daughter's open heart surgery, starting my final year of school and then a few major work projects, the blog got lost in the shuffle for a bit. 

Last week however, I started on a cooking binge and the first thing on the clip board to try were these chess squares.  I read the blog that posted the recipe and realized they were reminiscent to her of another recipe.  I thought they sounded (and looked) like something I used to have at my grandmas.  So the sleuth in me kicked in, and a hunting I went, trying to find the progression on the variations of  this recipe and ultimately, the origins.

Searching for "Chess Squares" took me to Nieman Marcus Bars, which led me to the Nieman Marcus Website and their Butter Cake.

I then found the Paula Deen "Gooey Butter Cake recipe" - which is no different than all the other recipes for Chess Squares out there, but she called it…

Stuffed Cube Steak

The other day, I had a hankering for cube steak, but did not want Swiss Steak or
Chicken Fried Steak - my usual go to's.  I wanted to do something else with cube steak
and remembered I had bookmarked a recipe from Pinterest that involved cube steak, bacon
and goat cheese.  I tried it, we liked it, and it is now in the regular dinner rotation.
I also discovered that this recipe can be done on the grill and is quite tasty either
broiled or grilled.  You dont need a potato or rice dish with it.  A really nice salad
and some crusty bread with some homemade lemonade really makes this a great summer meal.
It is also very quick.  Just what we all want out of our summer dishes!

Stuffed Cube Steak

Serves 4

4 Cube steaks
salt and pepper to taste
4 oz cream cheese (or goat cheese) softened - very soft.
2 T coconut oil
1 small sweet onion (Vidalia or Maui) finely chopped
4 garlic cloves, crushed
2 c baby spinach - stems removed and coarsely chopped
6-8 slices sun dried tomatoes, julienned